Ex parte Dolores Owen, individually and as personal representative of the estate of Patricia Owen, deceased; In re: Dolores Owen, individually and as personal representative of the estate of Patricia Owen, deceased
Tennessee Valley Printing Company, Inc., d/b/a the Decatur Daily
Released for Publication August 5, 2015.
PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE COURT OF CIVIL APPEALS. (Morgan Circuit Court, CV-11-900327; Court of Civil Appeals, 2130139). Glenn E. Thompson, Trial Judge.
For Petitioner: Dennis E. Goldasich, Jr., Justin C. Owen, Goldasich & Associates, LLC, Birmingham.
MURDOCK, Justice. Stuart, Bolin, Parker, Shaw, Main, Wise, and Bryan, JJ., concur. Moore, C.J., dissents.
WRIT DENIED. NO OPINION.
MOORE, Chief Justice (dissenting).
On August 31, 2011, Leon Johnson (" Leon" ) was delivering newspapers when his vehicle struck Patricia Owen (" Patricia" ), causing injuries that eventually led to her death. On September 11, 2011, Dolores Owen, individually and as personal representative of Patricia's estate (" Owen" ), brought a wrongful-death action against the Tennessee Valley Printing Company d/b/a The Decatur Daily (" TVPC" ). Owen alleged that on the day of the accident Leon was delivering TVPC's newspapers for his wife Carolyn Johnson (" Carolyn" ), who had a contract with TVPC to deliver copies of The Decatur Daily. TVPC moved for a summary judgment, arguing that it was not liable for Patricia's death because, it said, Carolyn was an independent contractor, not its agent. The trial court granted TVPC's summary-judgment motion. Owen appealed to the Court of Civil Appeals, which affirmed the judgment of the trial court.
Ex parte Owen, [Ms. 2130139, Aug. 8, 2014] 168 So.3d 1221 (Ala.Civ.App. 2014). Owen then petitioned this Court for a writ of certiorari, which the Court now denies.
In order to establish an agency relationship between Carolyn and TVPC, Owen must have shown that TVPC had the right to dictate not only the results of Carolyn's work but also the manner in which it would be done. Jenkins v. Gadsden Times Publ'g Co., 521 So.2d 957, 958 (Ala. 1988); Brown v. Commercial Dispatch Publ'g Co., 504 So.2d 245, 246 (Ala. 1987); and Atchison v. Boone Newspapers, Inc., 981 So.2d 427, 431 (Ala.Civ.App. 2007).
Owen's petition states:
" Carolyn Johnson testified that when she began delivering Decatur Daily newspapers, someone from The Decatur Daily, an area manager or district manager named 'Tina,' would ride with her on her route during her first two or three days delivering newspapers. Carolyn Johnson testified that the individual from The Decatur Daily who rode with her on her home delivery route would give her instruction and direct her on how to deliver the newspapers. Carolyn Johnson testified that she considered the ride-along with the person from The Decatur Daily ...